Warning: Avoid NVTrimmer for Nvidia driver customization

[German]Within the last days I’ve seen several blog posts recommending the tool NVTrimmer. The tool is used for customizing Nvidia driver installation packages. If you intend to use this tool, read this blog post to become aware of the risks.


Advertising


At this point I’d like to make a clear: It’s not my intension to criticizes my blogging colleagues. At a first glance it’s a good idea to have such a tool, and I value the intension of the developer of this tool. But, if you think you need that tool, you should at least have read the following explanations and be aware of the potential consequences.

NVTrimmer, what’s that?

Martin Brinkmann introduced NVTrimmer on ghacks.net a few days ago – here is his tweet.

With this tool you can customize a Nvidia driver installation packag. The screenshot shown in the tweet above indicates the options for customization, which looks tempting. Martin Brinkmann wrote:

NVIDIA Driver Slimming Utility (NVSlimmer) is a free portable program for Windows to remove unwanted components from Nvidia drivers before installation.

Sounds reasonable, and the tool has been introduced within the guru3d forum. I’ve read Martin’s blog post an thought ‘you need to check this tool, sounds good’.


Advertising

Trouble after NVSlimmer 0.5 download

Within the article linked above (and another German article), version 0.4 of the tool has been tested. Visiting the guru3d forum I found version 0.5, which I downloaded in Windows 7 SP1. Then I tried to have a look into the ZIP archive, using a double click (my intention was, to use Windows build in features for that).

ZIP-Fehler 1

But I got the message shown above on my German Windows, that says ‘Could not open the folder, due to the ZIP compressed folder … is not valid’. First I thought the download was damaged. But other copies produced the same behavior. My attempt, to unzip the archive, using Windows 7 context menu command, ends with the error message below:

ZIP-Fehler beim Entpacken

It says that the ZIP archive is empfty, obviously the archive was packed with options that are not supported in Windows 7 SP1. I then reluctantly tried 7-Zip, but already received an error message during unpacking. Finally I opened the ZIP archive in 7-Zip with a double click and was able to view files. These could then be expanded by drag & drop into a new folder.

Addenum: I know now the reason, why I can’t unzip the archive (a German reader posted a comment). The download is saved as a .zip archive file, but the content is packed as RAR – I’ve overlooked this in 7-Zip.

Frowning over the expanded files

When I looked into the folder with the unzipped files, I found libraries and auxiliary routines of 7-Zip are used there. The following screenshot shows the contents of the folder.

NVSlimmer-Dateien

The 7-Zip utilities and files are version 18.5.0.0 (dated April 30, 2018). This is the current version (see also my blog post 7-ZIP Version 18.05 released). But I had explained in this article as well as in the blog post Security-Risk: Avoid 7-Zip the potential security problems with 7-Zip, and that’s why I hesitate to use these utilities. Obviously NVTrimmer needs these tools to unpack and repack the NVidia driver archives.

Addenum: Ok, they are using the least recent 7-zip version, and Igor Beltchev seems to have improved the security of 7-zip. But it’s important, to keep in mind, to check after downloading a new version of NVSlimmer, that these files also has been updated.

Red alert within my security test bed

Since a while I have begun to test such new tools also within a security test bed. There I can check if a program is vulnerable to DLL hijacking or having obvious security issues. In this test environment I use test modules provided by security expert Stefan Kanthak (see also my article PSA: Classic Shell is now Open Shell Menu – and a warning). The modules will trigger an alarm, if something is not properly implemented.

Sicherheitsalarm bei NVTrimmer 0.5

Executing NVTrimmer within my security test bed triggered one ‘mine after the other’. The dialog box shown above is in German, but it says, that NVSlimmer.exe is using a dll from my test bed. The dialog was one of many similar messages. NVTrimmer not only uses the insecure 7-Zip auxiliary tools, but also has a lot of static dependencies to various DLL libraries.

This opens an attack vector to DLL hijacking for malware. It doesn’t even need admin privileges to manipulate or inject things. And now people are using this tool to read a Nvidia driver package, select some options and then let the tool reassemble it into a modified driver package. This driver package will be installed later in Windows with administrator privileges.

So this provides a wonderful attack vector for malware. This malware of course could inject everything into the driver package that you need in terms of malicious functions. I won’t say ‘it happens’, but I point out a potential risk that should be avoided in a ‘good programming practice’. So I would keep my fingers away from such a tool.


Advertising


This entry was posted in Security, Windows and tagged , . Bookmark the permalink.

2 Responses to Warning: Avoid NVTrimmer for Nvidia driver customization

  1. CHEF-KOCH says:

    What you write is totally BS (sorry to say this).

    1.) NVtrimmer is basically only a GUI for which you can do via a simple batch file, except that it also offers additional features like repacking/compressing the files which you chose within the GUI (optional process).
    2.) Download issue has nothing to do with the program itself. If Guru3d has some troubles I’m sure they’re working on it ASAP in order to fix this. That some files/articles are sometimes are not available is normal, probably because of maintenance etc.
    3.) The program is harmless you can also verify that via VirusTotal or internal tools to check what’s going on behind the scene. Your warning is nothing but a false positive.
    4.) Yes 7-zip is used to compress the files (repacking) in order to save HDD/SSD space, 7-zip is fully open source.
    5.) DWMAPI + UXtheme are not called using the program itself, it’s maybe only a back function in order to draw the GUI (written in .NET assuming it tries to check threme layout to avoid several things).

    The only part I see here to complain is that the original author didn’t release the source code which makes it harder (but not impossible) to audit the program or to find/fix possible issues. Possible dll hijacking or manipulating is possible in all programs unless the author specifically added some extra checks for this in it and even then it can be bypassed (see basically every cracked game). This, however, doesn’t mean the program is insecure or dangerous if it would be dangerous someone already had figured out and it wouldn’t be featured on Guru3d.

    • guenni says:

      Just read the article and then re-read your reply. None of your points above addresses, what I pointed out. You wasted a lot of text to negate something, that I never raised within my text. Sorry, your text is pretty useless.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *