Windows 10 V1803 and above: No more RegBack

[German]Windows 10 stops to auto back up copies of the registry into the RegBack folder since version 1803. Microsoft recently announced this within a support article. 


Advertising

This is a supplement to a topic I thought was generally known. I remember my blog post Windows 10: No RegBack backup in V1803/1809 of November 5, 2018 where I described that issue. Here are some excerpts from my older post an an explanation provided by Microsoft including a workaround on how to get back the old behavior.

Some Background

Windows contains a feature that creates a backup copy of the registry files at regular intervals. Windows uses a folder C:\Windows\System32\config\RegBack in which the operating system can cyclically store copies of its registry files. There is a task in the branch Microsoft -> Windows -> Registry in the task planner for this purpose.

Task für Registry-Backup

This task cyclically creates various files in the RegBack folder. I checked this under Windows 7 times in an administrative command prompt. This looks like this:

Registrierungsdateien in RegBack


Advertising

The system-wide valid structure files of the registry (hives) can be found. In SOFTWARE, for example, all installed programs can be found and under SYSTEM the registration keys for the system are stored.

This feature should allow you to repair a Windows that is no longer starting due to damaged registry hives. In the past, however, there have been problems with the feature from time to time.

RegBack is missing since Windows 10 V1803

In Windows 10 Version 1803/1809 the registry backup task doesn't work anymore. If you inspect the RegBack folder, you will see, it is empty, although there is a backup task.

RegBack-Ordner in Windows 10 V809

Even a manual execution of the task to backup the registry hive files does not change this. I then searched the Internet – this forum entry in MS Answers from June 7, 2018 complains about this effect already on Windows 10 V1803. A user writes that the files would have a size of 0 kb. Other users confirm these observations. It is assumed that Microsoft silently 'killed' the registry backup from Windows 10 V1803. In version 1809 the folder is even completely empty.

This tweet from Vadim Sterkin @vsterkin also already discussed this observation for Windows 10 V1803, and some people try to bring it to the attention of the Microsoft developers in the feedback hub or via Twitter.

Microsoft finally delivers an explanation

The last days I have seen on several websites the reference to the Microsoft support document The system registry is no longer backed up to the RegBack folder starting in Windows 10 version 1803, dated June 29, 2019. The document refers to Windows 10 version 1803 and higher. It confirms that from Windows 10 version 1803, Windows no longer automatically backs up the system registry in the RegBack folder. If you control the folder \Windows\System32\config\RegBack with Windows Explorer, the registry hive will appear, but each file is 0 kb in size.

This change is intended by Microsoft and is intended to reduce the footprint of Windows 10 with respect to the total size of the occupied disk space. To restore a system with a corrupted registry hive, Microsoft recommends that you use a System Restore Point.

However, I consider this advice to be a joke of history and wonder what kind of weed they smoke in Redmond. First of all, the 'footprint' caused by the hive files is small compared to the bloatware that Microsoft pumps onto the systems with useless apps and features. But the kidding can be increased – because for quite some time each feature update deactivates during the system recovery feature including automatic creation of recovery points.

How to force legacy Registry backups

If you want to reactivate the behavior of the legacy backups from older versions of Windows 10, you can configure this via the following registry entry: :

HKLM\System\CurrentControlSet\Control\Session Manager\Configuration Manager\EnablePeriodicBackup
Typ: REG_DWORD Wert: 1

Set the DWORD value EnablePeriodicBackup to 1 and restart the computer. Windows saves the registry in the RegBack folder when the computer is restarted and creates a RegIdleBackup task to manage subsequent backups. Windows stores the task information in the Scheduled Task Library in the Microsoft\Windows\Registry folder. The task has the properties shown in the following figure:

(Source: Microsoft)

Similar articles:
Windows 10 Mai 2019 Update released
Windows 10 N: Media Feature Pack for Version 1903 released
Windows 10 V1803 threatens a forced update as of July 2019
Windows 10 V1903: Known Issues – Part 1
Windows 10 V1903: Known Issues – Part 2
Windows 10 V1803: Force update to V1903 – Part 1


Cookies helps to fund this blog: Cookie settings
Advertising


This entry was posted in Windows and tagged . Bookmark the permalink.

2 Responses to Windows 10 V1803 and above: No more RegBack

  1. Christoph says:

    Hey Guenni thx for sharing,

    good to know that this is gone. I guess you will only notice it if you need the backup -_-

    another way is to create the backup with reg.exe

    reg.exe save HKLM\security c:\temp\sec
    reg.exe save HKLM\SAM c:\temp\sam
    reg.exe save HKLM\SYSTEM c:\temp\sys

    have a nice one

    • Hobbyadmin says:

      > I guess you will only notice it if you need the backup -_-

      True. Noticed that today when working on a customer laptop, it needs a complete reinstall now only due to some bad timing with a current update while running out of battery which corrupted "system". The change to disable these backups is a really bad joke.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.