Windows 10 2004: Storage Spaces issues

[German]The recently released Windows 10 May 2020 Update (version 2004) contains many bugs. Administrators in enterprise environments that rely on storage spaces should wait with the upgrade. There are issues with storage spaces. I've put together a few things for your information.


What is Storage Spaces?

Storage Spaces is a technology introduced by Microsoft for Windows clients and Windows servers to protect data from drive errors. The technology is conceptually similar to RAID, but is implemented by software. Users can use storage space to group two or more drives into a storage pool and then use the capacity from that pool to create storage. Multitier caching of HDDs (if necessary of different manufacturers / speeds) by means of SSDs is also possible. These usually store additional copies of the data. If a drive from this group fails, Windows can still access an intact copy of the data.

When the capacity of a storage space is exhausted, administrators can simply add more drives to the storage pool. Microsoft has described this in this document for Windows Server. And the Wikipedia provides a description of the function for Windows 8 here..

Error 0x00000057  known for months

One issue that has been bothering administrators for months is the 0x00000057 error when creating new storage space storage pools. On Microsoft Answers you can find this thread from September 2019, which deals with the Storage Spaces Error 0x00000057. There are also several entries in the Microsoft Feedback Hub (see for example

Storage Spaces Error 0x00000057

Users will not be able to create new storage spaces pool or volumes. The post referred to a Windows 10 Insider Preview Build 18951.1 (the development branch that culminated in Windows 10 version 2004). Jason from Microsoft has also talked to the responsible developers – but when browsing through the 3 pages, little came up. A moderator, Don Culbert, responded with a post naming PowerShell commands that could be used to create the required operation. There was no real resolution. Now I read at Windows Latest,  that the Storage Spaces Error 0x00000057 is still an issue – the management interface is probably pretty broken.


Probable reason: Powershell does not know the new version level for pools. In Powershell only the creation of a pool in Version-Level Server 2019 is possible. The upgrade of the Pool Function Level can / must be done subsequently. It looks like I'm trying to create the GUI pools on the new level. This is a speculation why it still only works via Powershell, but not via GUI. German blog reader Karl mentioned it in this tweet. This was first reported in the Feedback Hub 8 months ago.

Windows 10 Version 2004 destroys parity storage

On there is this post, where a user points out another problem. In Windows 10 version 2004, there are probably memory errors with storage spaces:

Do not upgrade to 2004 if you're using parity storage spaces.

Ever since updating to 2004 I have been experiencing severe corruption & chkdsk errors on my parity drives (and only parity) in storage spaces. (See any of my recent post history) I managed to reproduce the corruption on a new pool, with a new set of disks, with a new set of SATA controllers, but I've been assuming I must have some other kind of hardware failure instead.

In this Reddit post, the affected person received confirmation that another user had the same experience after upgrading to Windows 10 version 2004. MSPU has collected a lot more here.

Deleting doesn't free any storage space

And there is another hammer with storage spaces, that affects all Windows 10 builds down to version 1903. I've had this topic on my agenda since spring, but I haven't gotten around to editing it here on the blog yet. If files are deleted in a storage space storage pool, this should cause the occupied storage to shrink again. Karl noticed that the volume formatted on a ReFS with mirroring (Mirror aka RAID 1) is not the case. He already mentioned the whole thing on Twitter in January 2020.

The tweet has a lot of follow up tweets where more information came. He suspected the RefFS filesystem, but then he found this technet forum thread and commented there. In his case, the effect affected Windows 10 Professional – an insider preview in the 20H1 development branch, which is now available as Windows 10 Version 2004.

This behavior also applies to Windows 1903 or later SAC Core Servers. If I haven't missed anything: As soon as a configured storage pool is reported as full, no more free storage can be created by deleting it. This affects pools with RefFS file system, for NTFS volumes the return of the storage pool works. Karl wrote me that the Windows 10 version 1909 with RefFS (without storage spaces) supports the return of free storage areas. It concludes that there is a bug in storage spaces that occurs in conjunction with RefFS.

Feedback-Hub with Storage Spaces entries

The execution of defrag optimization (slab consolidation) makes the situation worse.
The process zeroes unused memory areas and thus releases them again. Data is then "written" and fills the pool and the drives, but on the ReFS volumes it is not released again as usual.

Karl told me: All issues were professionally analyzed in Insider Fast versions of client and server with the Insider Team / Storage Team and completely fixed for the first time in version 19628. However, there is no backport of these fixes to the Windows 10 2004, 1909 and 1903 versions yet.

Defrag: In this context, it also led to various display issues with the Defrag tool, where always different values appeared during several optimization attempts.

Another error in Storage Spaces

Microsoft has confirmed another bug in this support document. In Windows 10 Version 2004 Storage Spaces partitions may show as RAW after an upgrade.

Similar articles:
Windows 10 Version 2004: Issues with Malwarebytes 4.1.0?
Windows 10 version 2004 annoys Chrome users
Windows 10 v2004 breaks Fresh Start
Windows 10 Version 2004/Windows Server 2004 released
Windows 10 Version 2004: Deprecated/removed features
Windows 10 version 2004: Graphics issues with multi monitor and f.lux
Windows 10 2004: ADMX templates available
Windows 10 Version 2004: External display turns black
Windows 10 Version 2004: Issues with DVBViewer drivers
Windows 10 2004: Upgrade fail due to drive letter on boot partition
Windows 10 Version 2004: Issue with Optane Systems
Windows 10 V2004: Office365 Sync issues with iCloud
Windows 10 V2004: Downloads removed from disk cleanup
Windows 10 Version 2004: Forced upgrade without user consent
Windows 10 Version 2004 Upgrade Issues with Surfaces
Upgrade Block to Windows 10 2004 for devices with Core isolation (HVCI)

Cookies helps to fund this blog: Cookie settings

This entry was posted in issue, Windows and tagged , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

10 Responses to Windows 10 2004: Storage Spaces issues

  1. Mark says:

    Hi, I upgraded to 2004 on my Windows Pro desktop, which uses Storage Spaces for its data drives, as NTFS volume. So far I haven't seen a problem, but I'm wondering if I should revert to 1909 while a solution is worked on. Advice very welcome

  2. Pingback: Windows 10 version 2004 slams into a Storage Spaces brick wall - ComputerWorld

  3. Pingback: Microsoft Resumes Month-to-month Non-compulsory Cumulative Updates for Home windows Methods - Redmond Mag

  4. Advertising

  5. Linus says:

    Hi have you or Karl received any updates on the REFS+StorageSpaces not releasing disk space when files are removed?

    I see a reference to internal build 19628… but can neither find any references to such a fix in that build, nor any references to when it could be released as a patch.

    Any update helps. It seems this issue gets largely ignored by MS

    • guenni says:

      I didn't got a feedback – I asked Karl, whether he noticed a change. Maybe he will post here a comment.

    • Karl Wester-Ebbinghaus (@tweet_alqamar) says:

      Hi Linus.
      Ignored is the wrong term. Rather low priority.

      It is still not solved for any server or client build from 1903 through 20h2.

      But they have now escalated the support ticket after not hearing anything from Devs.

      If you need it to be solved use insider dev channel. It is fixed there.

      • Linus says:

        Thank you Karl
        I'm hesitating to use the Dev channel for what is in essence the family home server a hub for way to many things to be allowed to be unstable. As long as writes to the now full array are limited it seems to work, but they are slow.

        Good to know that it has been escalated internally. Holding thumbs….

        • Jens H. says:

          Hey so the fix will not be available in the H2 update but only in the upcoming upgrade in 2021?, 'cause the h2 version is build 19042.

          so i have to wait until next year.

          could you test the insider build and confirm that freeing up refs storage space by deleting files will now work "again"?

          • Eliot says:

            Just installed 21H1, and tested volume-optimization on my 100% full ReFS mirror… …and it's still not fixed… Arrrgh!!! Microsoft!!!

  6. Pingback: Windows 10 variation 2004 slams into a Storage Areas brick wall | Computer World

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *